Appendices
Appendix A: Items to include in Terms of Reference
- Committee name
- Membership and constitution - As well as the committee membership, there may also be people who are there by virtue of the role they hold (Ex-officio members) and those who may be invited to certain meetings or for certain items, so that they can inform or be kept aware of relevant discussions.
- Terms of Reference (the remit of the committee)
- Sub-committees or sub-groups
- Committees or groups to which the committee reports. It may be helpful to draft an organogram to display this, such as in the example below.
- Frequency of meetings
- Date of last revision
Faculty Committees
- The Terms of Reference for the Faculty’s committees.
As an example of good practice, view the Terms of Reference for the Humanities Postgraduate Research Committee.
Example organogram showing reporting lines:
Appendix B: Agenda template
As a guide, business should be ordered and organised as follows, but this can be agreed and adapted as appropriate by the committee Chair and Secretary.
- The date, time and place of the meeting.
- Membership, including welcome to new members or attendees.
- Apologies (the names of the attendees who could not be present at the meeting).
- Confirmation of minutes of the previous meeting.
- Consideration of matters arising from these minutes and review of action list
- The main agenda items for discussion. For many committees this may include:
a. Unreserved Business
i. Chair's report
ii. Student business
iii. Items requiring resolution by the committee
iv. Items for approval without discussion
v. Reports from sub-committees or from members
vi. Receipt of minutes of sub-committees
b. Other matters for information only. Usually a ‘starred item’ by adding an asterisk* to the item
(but can be unstarred if requested of the Secretary / Chair in advance of the meeting).
c. Any other business
- The date and time of the next meeting
a. Reserved business (see below)
For less formal meetings, such as weekly team get-togethers, the agenda may simply provide a list of the main agenda items.
Creating main agenda items
Following the suggestions outlined below will help you to prepare main agenda items effectively.
- Prioritise your agenda. The most important points should be addressed at the start of the meeting, with more time allocated to them than to lower-priority issues. These should be addressed towards the end of the meeting.
- Establish how much time is available for the meeting and then allocate a period of time in which to address each agenda point. Doing this will help to ensure that all the necessary issues are addressed in the time available.
- For each agenda point, clarify what exactly will be discussed, and how it will be addressed. For example, ‘brainstorm ideas for new business generation’ would be a more helpful agenda point than ‘new business ideas’.
- Before finalising the agenda, it is a good idea to invite the members to contribute items to the agenda. This will ensure that everything is covered and help attendees feel more involved and engaged with the meeting.
- The agenda and any other relevant documentation should be circulated among all attendees and any other interested parties at an appropriate point in advance of the meeting, usually a week before.This will provide others with the chance to read the papers, reflect on the agenda items and prepare effectively for the meeting.
- It is good practice to bring a spare copy of the agenda and papers with you, in case anyone forgets to print their own copies.
Informed by ‘Top Tips for Using Agendas and Minutes’ on the Staff Learning and Development Unit’s ‘Learning and Development Toolkit’.
Example agenda template
The University of Manchester
Faculty of Humanities Postgraduate Research Committee
A meeting of the above Committee will be held on [DATE], [TIME], [VENUE]
For any queries, please contact [Email]
Agenda
Unreserved business
Item |
Topic |
Purpose[1] |
Paper |
1. |
Apologies for absence [List any apologies received in advance] |
For info |
|
2. |
Minutes and actions Confirmation of minutes of the meeting held on 6 December 2017 |
To approve |
yes |
2.1. |
Matters arising |
|
|
2.2. |
HEFCE Catalyst Fund Supporting PGR mental health bid |
For info |
|
3. |
Exit survey |
For discussion |
|
4. |
PGR review process |
For discussion |
yes |
5. |
SoSS follow-up response from PGR review |
For info |
yes |
6. |
Scopus data – Stephen Pearson to attend |
For info |
|
7. |
PGR-Research alignment |
For discussion |
yes |
7.1. |
Annual monitoring |
For info |
|
8. |
PRES action plan |
For info |
To be tabled |
9. |
First Generation Project report |
For info |
yes |
10. |
Summary of award recommendations |
For info |
yes |
11. |
Report/issues from schools |
|
|
12. |
Report/issues from student representative |
|
|
13. |
Chair’s report |
For info |
yes |
14. |
Activities’ reports:
|
For info |
yes |
15. |
Recruitment data |
For info |
yes |
16. |
Any other business |
|
|
17. |
Themes for future PGR Committee strategy meetings |
For discussion |
|
18. |
Item for future discussion |
|
|
19. |
Date of next meeting |
|
|
[1] The coversheet for any papers should outline the purpose of the discussion.
Reserved business
Item |
Topic |
Purpose |
Paper |
20. |
List of Chair’s Actions (special permission) |
For info |
ü |
Circulation
- List names of members
- List names of colleagues to whom papers should be sent for information
Appendix C: Cover sheet for committees and meetings template
What should be on a cover sheet for the meeting.
- Title of paper submitted:
- Author:
- Intended recipient(s) (please delete/add meeting title as appropriate)
- DAG
- SMT
- HPRC
- Date of meeting:
- Purpose of document (please delete as appropriate):
- For information
- For discussion and/or feedback
- For endorsement before onward transmission to SMT or HPRC
- For decision
- For approval
- *Policy document – (i) draft for discussion/consultation;
- *Policy document - (ii) final version for approval and implementation
- Private and Confidential
- Please outline the key points for discussion, and specify the desired outcome of the paper being presented at the meeting.
- Communication of outcomes and next steps:
- To whom should decisions made at the meeting be communicated? (Eg the author of the paper, another committee...)
- Who else should be notified of the decisions made, and by whom?
- When will the decisions be shared?
- For policy documents only (Delete this section if not appropriate)
For (i) draft policy documents, please indicate method of consultation – eg via AD committees, via HPRC, etc;
For (ii) final version policy documents for approval and implementation, please include the following information:
Implementation date |
|
Owner |
|
Review date |
|
To be communicated via |
eg posted to the Faculty intranet; Faculty wide e-mail, via briefings e.g. core brief, school boards, SPRCs etc. |
Appendix D: Quick tips for writing minutes
Depending on the nature of the meeting, the minutes should capture some, or all of the following aspects:
- the date, time and venue of the meeting;
- the name of the person leading the meeting (Chair);
- the names of all the attendees (and full names, with initials, using initials for action points);
- agenda topics covered;
- definition of problems, issues or challenges discussed;
- the alternatives/solutions presented in the meeting;
- details of any decisions made;
- the agreed action points, the person(s) responsible for delivering them, and the timescales and/or deadlines identified;
- the date and time of the next meeting.
The format for your minutes should be consistent and ideally you should be working from one template (see appendix E for a suggested template).
Taking effective minutes
Following these suggestions will help you, or an appointed attendee, to take minutes effectively during a meeting.
- Minutes can be taken in a variety of ways. Using pen and paper, typing straight into a laptop or hand-held device, and recording the meeting using a dictaphone are all valid methods of minute-taking (you may wish to inform the attendees if using the latter). As long as it doesn’t disrupt the meeting, the Secretary should be allowed to use the method that works best for them.
- If you are new to the committee, familiarise yourself with previous minutes so you are aware of the acronyms, areas under discussion and action points. At the first meeting ask everyone to introduce themselves and draw a table plan so you can remember who is who.
- If you are not sure of a point that has been agreed, do not be afraid to ask for clarification during the meeting.
- Using the agenda, you may wish to start drafting an initial outline of the minutes in advance of the meeting. This can save valuable time during the meeting, allowing you to record information and participate in the meeting (if appropriate) more readily.
- Minutes should capture the key discussion points and outcomes of the meeting, rather than a word-for-word transcript of it.
- Do not summarise reports that have been circulated with the meeting, even if the author has summarised for the benefit of the committee attendees. Simply state that the paper was noted by the Committee and note any action points arising from the discussion.
Useful Phrases
- The paper/report was noted.
- The (name of the guest) briefed the committee
- The Committee members discussed the item and concluded….
- A decision was delayed until the next meeting
- While it is acceptable to identify individuals where they are acting in their professional capacity such as presenting a report or other scheduled item, it is not recommended to identify individual participants together with their opinions. If it is necessary to note the opinions have a sub-heading ‘Noted’ and bullet the points beneath.
- It is good practice to write the minutes up within 24 hours of the meeting. The minute-taker is likely to find it easier to reflect the content of the meeting accurately when it is still fresh in their mind.
- Information in the minutes should be presented clearly and concisely; bullet points, headings and lists can all be useful ways of doing this.
- The wording of the minutes must be simple, precise and easy to read. Use plain English and avoid flowery language and keep your sentences short and to the point. Grammar should be past tense in the third person e.g. Donald Duck agreed to consult with undergraduate students and report back to the next meeting.
- The draft minutes should be sent to the chair to check for accuracy. They should be marked as ‘unconfirmed’ until they are approved at the next meeting, at which point they can be marked as ‘confirmed’.
- Establish the most appropriate way for sharing the finalised minutes with the attendees and other interested parties. Depending on how it has been agreed that the minutes will be shared, you may wish to send them via email, add to Sharepoint, or post to the intranet.
Informed by ‘Top Tips for Using Agendas and Minutes’ on the Staff Learning and Development Unit’s ‘Learning and Development Toolkit’.
Appendix E: Template for writing minutes and recording actions
The University of Manchester
Faculty of Humanities – XXXX Committee
(Un)confirmed minutes of the meeting held on [Date] [Example template]
Present:
Apologies for absence:
|
Agenda item |
Reported/noted |
Actions, responsibility |
1. |
Apologies for absence |
|
|
2. |
Welcome to any new members or attendees |
|
|
3. | Confirmation of minutes of the previous meeting |
Minutes approved |
|
4. |
Matters arising and review of actions from the previous meeting |
||
4.1 |
|
|
|
4.2 |
|
|
|
5. |
Chair’s report |
|
|
6. |
Student business |
|
|
7. |
Items requiring resolution by the committee |
|
|
8. |
Items for approval without discussion |
|
|
9. |
Reports from sub-committees or from members |
|
|
10. |
Receipt of minutes of sub-committees |
|
|
11. |
Other matters for information only |
|
|
12. |
Any other business |
|
|
12.1. |
|
|
|
13. |
Date of next meeting |
|
|
Appendix F: Committee Actions log
Actions arising from meeting of 9 December 2015 | ||||
Item | Details of action | Responsibility | Notes | Status |
Actions arising from meeting of 7 December 2016 | ||||
Item | Details of action | Responsibility | Notes | Status |
Actions arising from meeting of 14 June 2017 | ||||
Item | Details of action | Responsibility | Notes | Status |
Appendix H: Glossary
AD External Relations - Associate Dean External Relations
AHRC - Arts & Humanities Research Council
AHRC DTP - Arts & Humanities Research Council Doctoral Training Partnership
AHRC NWCDTP - Arts & Humanities Research Council North West Consortium Doctoral Training Partnership
AVP (Environmental Sustainability) - Associate Vice President (Environmental Sustainability)
BWPI - Brookes World Poverty Institute
CMIST - Cathie Marsh Institute for Social Research
CNW - Centre for New Writing
CoDE - Centre on Dynamics of Ethnicity
CPD - Continuing Professional Development
DAG - Dean’s Advisory Group
E&D - Equality & Diversity
ERA - European Research Area
ESID - Effective States and Inclusive Development research centre
ESRC DTC - Economic and Social Research Council Doctoral Training Centre
ESRC - Economic and Social Research Council
EU - European Union
FairWRC - Fairness at Work Research Centre
FBAs - Fellows of the British Academy
FLT - Faculty Leadership Team
FOIA - Freedom of Information Act
FP - EU’s Framework Programmes for Research
GDPR - General Data Protection Regulation
GRAs - Graduate Research Assistants
GTAs - Graduate Teaching Assistants
HCRI - Humanitarian and Conflict Response Institute
HE - Higher education
HEFCE Higher Education Funding Council for England
HEFCE T income - Higher Education Funding Council for England Teaching income
HESC - Humanities Employability Sub-Committee
HKFUMHong - Kong Foundation for The University of Manchester
HPRC Humanities Policy and Resources Committee
HR - Human Resources
HTLC - Humanities Teaching and Learning Committee
ICP - Institute for Cultural Practices
IMG - Intake Management Group
KPI - Key Performance Indicator
LPN - Low Participation Neighbourhood
MAP - Manchester Access Programme
MICRA - Manchester Institute for Collaborative Research on Ageing
MIoIR - Manchester Institute of Innovation Research (formerly PREST)
MOOCs - Massive Open Online Courses
N8 - The N8 Research Partnership is a collaboration of the eight most research intensive universities in the North of England: Durham, Lancaster, Leeds, Liverpool, Manchester, Newcastle, Sheffield and York.
NAFUM - North American Foundation for The University of Manchester
NSS - National Student Survey
NS-SEC - National Statistics Socio-Economic Classification (groups 4-7)
NWC - North West Consortium
NWDTC - North West Doctoral Training College
PAG - Portfolio Advisory Group
PASC - Programme Approval Sub-committee
P&DR - Performance & Development Review
PDRs - Performance & Development Reviews
PG - Postgraduate
PGR - Postgraduate Research
PGT - Postgraduate Taught
PhDs - Doctors of Philosophy
PSS - Professional Support Services
RAE - Research Assessment Exercise [replaced by REF]
RBESS - Research and Business Engagement Support Services
RCUK - Research Councils UK
REF - Research Excellence Framework [replaced RAE]
RoRFA - Review of Research Finance and Administration
SCI - Sustainable Consumption Institute
Shanghai Jiao Tong - world rankings
SMT - Senior Management Team
SSRs - Student Staff Ratio
STDU - Staff Training & Development Unit (Now SLD or Staff L&D – Staff Learning and Development)
UG - Undergraduate